Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing

Updated September 26, 2026 · Nashville Roofing Experts editorial team

Compare complete estimates

Choosing shingles or metal is just the start. Ask which products your roofer recommends, how they’ll be installed, and what happens to the old roof. Compare options for your own home, not just advertised lifespans or savings.

Appearance and product choice

Shingle estimates should identify the profile and color. Metal estimates should identify the material, panel profile, fastening system, and finish. Ask for physical samples and relevant contractor examples so you can judge the appearance beyond a screen image.

Roof fit and details

Have each contractor explain the roof slopes, transitions, and openings in their estimate. Discuss separate systems for any portion that does not suit the main covering. Do not assume one material can be applied identically to every roof section.

Installation and future work

Ask about removal, deck condition, deliveries, access, and weather delays. For future maintenance, find out who can perform repairs, how additions are handled, and what the manufacturer asks owners to inspect or maintain.

Warranty comparison

Ask for copies of the material and installation warranties. Check what’s covered, what isn’t, whether you need to register, and what happens if you sell your home.

Compare your priorities

Think about the look you like, your budget, how long you plan to stay, and how much upkeep you’re comfortable with. Ask your roofer which option best fits those plans.

Explore asphalt shingle roofing, metal roofing, and the replacement cost checklist.

Helpful tips for planning your roofing project. Your roof’s condition, the materials you choose, and local rules will shape the work. About our content.